#25. CHVRCHES - Gun (#37, 2013)
3rd of 2013
When an artist hits you with their lightning bolt of a single, it's very easy to rest in the temptation that it'll never be better than this. They figured it out, tapped into something special, and everything going forward will only feel like lingering attempts to capture that lightning again. Honestly, the task just gets harder because even if they do manage to do something that scratches that same itch, it's also something that's already been scratched. I'm laughing as I realise the last time I brought up GoldenEye 007 was when I was talking about an early CHVRCHES single (#305), but I have a slightly different reason this time. It's a game that gets significantly hailed largely because a wide range of millennials have specific memories pertaining to it that can't be replicated. Maybe fans from then just like that particular style of gameplay too much and can't let go of it in lieu of improvements to the genre (I was like this at the time, I found Halo difficult to get into, initially), but I think even in those bounds, you've got Perfect Dark just sitting there. The spiritual sequel from the same developers on the same console that does basically everything better (minus some frame rate issues). The only thing it really lacks is those memories and associations, because it came out a little later and less people played it.
To be clear, I am not suggesting that the early run of singles released by CHVRCHES could also be perceived in that kind of objective way, merely that it's how my experience runs with it. Initially, "The Mother We Share" was that monster. This borderline perfect song that looked at this synth pop style that was going around and refined it into something that ticked all the boxes. It was playful, bouncy, euphoric, and just felt like the platonic ideal of what this band I barely knew were capable of. You'd like to think there'd be some more gas in the tank, but you're realistic.
The funny thing about this is that it's my very tendency to canonise my music interests into a weekly chart that allows me to make these new revelations come forward. At the moment, I'm really into the new single by Florence Road, "7563". It's quite new so it feels strange for me to declare that it's my favourite song from them so far, but I have the equivalent of a receipt that tells me it's quickly become the most invested I've been in them (and recent events have had me more mentally attached to it). This kind of recognition takes time to fully settle in, but sometimes you can jump the gun because you can map out the trajectory.
In the case of CHVRCHES, I can't fully use this same method just because I went so all-in on "The Mother We Share". In the almost 18 years of me making personal charts, that song is one of only 6 to ever debut at #1. Any further commendations for CHVRCHES' discography comes with the caveat that you have to make justifications around the respective competition, or just my tendency to not get overzealous like that quite as often (it's been nearly 10 years since the last of those #1 debuts). Still, CHVRCHES have had another 3 #1's since that first one, so I must have been content to let them all share the spotlight, as I don't consider myself to loosely hand out that commendation any time one of my favourites is back.
"Gun" was the first of those three. In one sense it might be the most surprising of them all because it largely does not come with any new bells and whistles. It is not a song that will remotely shake your understanding of what CHVRCHES are capable of, and feels like a prime candidate to be washed away as 'just another one'. Nonetheless, adhering to the formula meant that it caught on very quickly with me and then just stuck the landing from there. It didn't take long for me to declare it my favourite CHVRCHES song of all, something I stuck with for many years. There's just something about the finishing touches on it. This time around, the vocal melody feels more grounded to the rest of the song, which I think gives it a bit more power. The hook gets stuck in your head, and the corresponding drums just hammer it in there to keep it stuck. CHVRCHES' later material took them in slightly different directions, but now this is the song that feels like the ideal version of the first iteration.
This is where I do inevitably have to give shout outs to the later material. I've already been very glowing with their second album "Every Open Eye", which feels like an iteration on the first album in all the best ways. I'm actually not sure they've done better with that template since then, which is why my other favourite CHVRCHES songs have been the ones that sound nothing like this. The first one that caught me off guard is their song "Death Stranding", from the video game of the same name. It's pure end credits music but they strike a beautiful balance between the hard-hitting and softer moments, so neither feels like a distraction or filler between the other. Then, a couple of years later, they teamed up with Robert Smith and provided the unexpected monster that is "How Not To Drown". That song has them practically abandoning synth pop and going straight for edgy alternative rock, though still retaining their gift for hooks. This is what I was listening to when I wasn't getting any of my votes into the Hottest 100 and I don't regret the path I took.



.jpg)


