#885. Vance Joy - Riptide (#1, 2013)
92nd of 2013
Probably the most inexplicable song of my lifetime. This isn't even necessarily an insult. I'd probably subject any song with the same amount of longevity to the same scrutiny. There is admittedly the famous band that from Las Vegas that isn't Imagine Dragons who will eventually appear on this list though. I have a slightly easier time wrapping my head around that one. But even then, that's a song that's had peaks & valleys, it comes in and out of its cage. Ever since early 2013, outside of Christmas, you can never look at Australia's Spotify chart and not see this song jumping around with zero sign of fatigue. This song reached its highest ever daily streaming total in Australia in September of 2024, there's a very solid chance I'll have to edit this by the time it's posted because it'll probably peak again (Note: I did not).
If you're into it, there's a solid fairytale charm in this. In 2013, there were two distinct moments of 'well, this song is winning the Hottest 100'. The first was when Daft Punk dropped the sound of the summer, and the second was when Lorde took the world by storm. These two songs are not forgotten by any stretch (and will eventually appear in this list), but after all that pressure & anticipation, ended up falling short of just some guy who used to play in the VFL but wasn't good enough to play for Richmond during their late 2000s slump (maybe they could call him up now in their new 2020s slump, he's only a month older than the AFL's oldest current player). You can look at it as a standard affair of getting behind the Australian underdog, but clearly the voters were onto something. At the time I'm writing this, "Riptide" is outperforming those other two songs combined on global daily streams by 50%. You can point to the plethora of TV commercials it was on at the time, but the billions of listens it has gotten from people far afield of that influence means that Vance Joy has more than justified his placing, not that he ever needed to.
But there's only so long I can spend analysing music as if it's not something I actually listen to. "Riptide" as a song itself does not offer very much to dig into. When it comes down to it, it's just another stomp & holler song. Between Mumford & Sons, and Of Monsters and Men, we very nearly had 3 of them topping the Hottest 100 in the space of 5 years. But this feels like a regression compared to those two, where the only apparent ambition this time around is in making a silly music video that seems to be making fun of itself.
The best compliment I can really think of is that it pairs the awkwardness of the lyrics with Vance Joy's wavering, breaking voice. He's not in any position to be confident, nor does he pretend to. I'd say it's part of the song's charm but I don't really know. I know that there definitely were times when I was more engaged in this song but it's been a long time now. The fact that I've never been able to go more than a week in history without having to be reminded of this song and its perpetuity really just doesn't give me a chance to grow that fondness back up. You cannot be nostalgic for something that's never gone away.
#884. The Cat Empire - Wolves (#79, 2015)
88th of 2015
It's so hard to get back on the horse. It's called the Hottest 100 for good reason. Plenty of artists right now are racking up entries while they're hot. Have an off year though, and it feels so difficult to fight back against that momentum. The Cat Empire's first two albums were huge. The third still did very well. The fourth sold well but didn't have a hit, and didn't crack the Hottest 100 in 2010. They felt like old news going forward. They inexplicably snuck into the 2013 list, and it felt like a last hurrah. But then they did it again 2 years later and it just felt so strange.
If you live in Australia, it's hard not to encounter The Cat Empire in some form. "Hello" never stops popping up (it's been on a TV commercial not so long ago). Whenever I hear the belter that is the GWS Giants theme song, I have to remember that it's a Harry James Angus composition. When I was young, I remember getting excited to hear "The Chariot" on the radio, as it just felt so ambitious and out there. Maybe I was born about half a decade late to have a ska phase.
Truth be told though, I do think as a band, they bring more to the table than just fulfilling their template of being on the Bluesfest line up every 2 years and phoning it in. Most of their popular songs over the years don't sound a lot like each other. From their past Hottest 100 entries I'd say "So Many Nights" feels like a bit of a rehash, but that's it.
"Wolves" leaves me without much to say though. It just feels a bit devoid of character from them at this point. That's all fine really, but it just feels like the jumping off point where they shouldn't still be polling like this. Even sneaking into the top 200 is a bit much for a song like this. It's tightly wound but there's not much to seek out in it. Frankly it's odd that this song has a 'gonna run like wolves' chorus, and the next song on the album is called "Bulls". That came 20 spots short of making the 2016 Hottest 100, which would be the finally ridiculous cherry on this long-preserved cake, but I do think I prefer that song. The ska life chose me I guess.
#883. Post Malone - Circles (#11, 2019)
86th of 2019
As a long time follower of music charts, I've often felt fairly estranged by what feel like consensus picks. They're the songs that everyone can agree on as being good. It really has me questioning how people assess music because so consistently, it feels less about having outstanding qualities, and more about lacking anything that would make anyone get angry or annoyed.
It's why I don't often have much interest in giving music scores and aggregating it. You always hear about how a 5/10 is worse than a 0/10 because at least the latter evokes a feeling, and yet these systems have a habit of empowering those 5/10s because they can never get a little bit of the vitriol required to put them in their place. I remember seeing people make fun of Anthony Fantano for not liking this song. Like it's so obviously good that anyone who thinks otherwise must be crazy. But it's for this song? Lionel Hutz would say 'There's a 5/10 >:(, and there's a 5/10 :)'.
Post Malone was riding a fair amount of good will and positive momentum at this point in time. His previous single "Goodbyes" wasn't astoundingly well received but it still spent 2 whole months in the top 10. Then "Circles" comes along. The cynical part of me wants to say that after years of straddling the line between rapper & pop star, "Circles" is the first one that goes all the way. No rapping, no guest rapper, no trap production.
It's not fair to dismiss it all in that way. In reality, I think I liked this song for a few months. Actually thanks to my obsessive cataloguing, I know that I did. I want to say it's because it sounded fairly fresh at the time, but then didn't offer much in return so it burned out on me quickly. It's another one of those songs that feel stuck in one tempo. The chorus is no longer cathartic, but induces a sense of tedium to dread. Seasons change, but this song is just running in circles.
The other thing to note is that this is probably the forerunner to one of my least favourite subsets of music, which is songs that sound thoroughly indebted to That One Tame Impala Song I Will Eventually Talk About. It's a trend that's suspiciously cropped up in the wake of That One Tame Impala Song I Will Eventually Talk About becoming a huge hit in every aspect except top 40 radio. Every time it always just feels like a hollow shell of what's being imitated, like getting a pass mark for hitting a similar bass line is all that's required. Until 2023, this was Post Malone's highest ever finisher in the Hottest 100, I guess it is all that was needed (Note: In hindsight I think I wrote this in a vague way with the assumption that he'd surpass this position again in 2024 but then he didn't end up doing so, so this is still his second highest position behind "Chemical").
#882. Alex The Astronaut - I Think You're Great (#55, 2020)
88th of 2020
This is Alex The Astronaut's second and to date, final Hottest 100 entry. If you thought that "Not Worth Hiding" got over the line with flying colours thanks to its direct subject matter, then it's surprising that this less distinct song still managed a fairly good finish. Maybe 2020 is just a strange year and it meant that a lot of different artists filled the void.
If there is a void to be filled with this song, it's that of a certain slacker rock artist from Melbourne who will eventually appear in this list. She didn't stop making music, but she did stop polling in the Hottest 100 sooner than you might have expected. This song doesn't have the dry witticisms that this comparison suggests, it's a fairly straight forward love song.
I don't want to leave this off with the impression that I'm extremely negative on Alex The Astronaut's music. I've always loved the song "Waste Of Time" from 2018, which in hindsight taps really well into that Pony Up! or Camera Obscura mould. At times you can just hit a certain chord progression and I'll go bananas for it. Other times, I don't have any particularly strong reaction.
#881. Vance Joy - Mess Is Mine (#13, 2014)
87th of 2014
Like many before him, Vance Joy landed in the spot of releasing a career-defining single right away with "Riptide" (#885), and having the task of following it up. It answers the question of whether "Riptide" was so popular because he's here to stay, or if it's all we'll need from him. As is often the case, the answer is somewhere in the middle. "Mess Is Mine" was successful, but not quite enough that you could imagine it being a hit without the one before it.
As a music and chart fan, it puts me in an odd position. If you ever feel like a hit song in the charts is just coasting by on an artist's good will, it can be more irritating than just something you dislike. At least people like those songs, this one's just limping over the line by default. That's how I felt with "Mess Is Mine" at the time.
It's a bit different to look back at this song with the context of a decade long career alongside it. It's easier to look at it on its own terms. Vance Joy has been accused at times of trying to catch another "Riptide" in a bottle. I don't think that's the case of this song though. If anything, this is the closest to a proto-typical Vance Joy song other than "Riptide". A modest bit of tempo that builds to the chorus and then just launching those horns at you.
That's a style that's drawn criticism in a different way. Ever since I had it pointed out to me, I've never been able to escape how much Vance Joy's entire schtick is reminiscent of Beirut. Beirut's only Hottest 100 entry, "Santa Fe" landed in 2011. I suspect a big reason why this similarity was noticed is because that song comes from an album called "The Rip Tide". There's a little bit of Vance Joy in that song, but not enough to really notice. I'm most fond of the 2006 song "Postcards From Italy" and that song is fully Vance Joy. Everything from the ukulele, the slightly garbled singing and it being drowned out by horns. It's a song I really love, and one that makes me have a high ceiling for expectations in Vance Joy because I'm sure he can hit the mark doing what he does. Maybe he already has. He's still got 6 more songs to appear here.