#23. Kendrick Lamar - HUMBLE. (#1, 2017)
5th of 2017
I am always fascinated trying to unpack the nature of an artist's most popular song. When I was talking about "True Lovers" (#422), I mentioned the notion of an artist's defining hit. There has to be something at the top of the pile, certainly, but what does it actually mean on an individual level? It's something where the economy has changed in the music streaming era. Success is no longer necessarily measured by the number of people you reach, but the extent in which you do. Granted, there are probably correlations between the two a lot of the time, but it's also interesting to break this down when you consider the two contributing groups: the ardent fans, and the dabbling outsiders. I feel as though the former group, through sheer volume of participation, have more of a say in this than ever before, though I've never been sure what the ratio between the two really is. When a popular artist releases a new song, it always feels like they're having to win over the audience anew, which implies casual curiosity. On the other hand, if they do hit that right spot with their fanbase, they're going to gradually reward them with repeated listens and I visualise the stats on that as being pretty similar regardless.
These are the strange thoughts I've always been trying to piece together when I think about "HUMBLE.". It is by some measures, Kendrick Lamar's most popular song, and that's the thing I've been trying to put together. It's easy to just say 'Oh yeah, this is clearly his populist anthem', but is it? I just have a hard time picturing the person who doesn't listen to Kendrick Lamar, but suddenly this song got some scarce amount of airplay on top 40 stations, and it was enough to warm them up to it. By all accounts it has to be just as, if not more abrasive than his music usually is and I just have a hard time picturing the person who has just this one song from him in their library.
In that case, you have to look at the fans, and I think that might provide the most realistic answer. Unless you just equally listen to his entire discography on shuffle, you're probably going to have your go-to choices in the mix. Maybe you're the kind of person who digs through all the albums to cherry-pick your favourites, or maybe you just pay attention to the ones that get the single treatment or show up in memes. I think what happens with all that is just a collation that adds up to "HUMBLE." being the song that ends up in the most of those selections.
As for why that is, I think sometimes the simplest answer tends to work out. It's simply the first applicable song of his he released with a proper rollout once he became seriously hot property. Maybe the opportunity was there with "To Pimp A Butterfly", but that clearly wasn't going in this direction, so rather than netting a major hit in the moment, it merely continued to present the potential launching pad that "DAMN." leapt up on. It was one thing to have a very respected and well regarded album with some moderate hits on it, but to follow it up with one of the most acclaimed albums of all time? That's gonna put you on nearly everyone's radar as one you can't just skip over.
Once you get to the music itself, there's something to be said that this still does manage to be Kendrick's most accessible song up to this point, maybe even beyond. He's obviously had songs before and since that are easier to play on the radio for being more chill and less aggressive, but sometimes you need that energy hit, and "HUMBLE." delivers it in spades. There's no waiting to find an ear-catching melody or lyric, this song will hit you straight in the gut and have you decide right away whether or not you want in. The result was striking. "HUMBLE." became Kendrick's first unmissable hit song, and the one that set the future standard for him. You'd be incredibly surprised to not see a proper new release immediately do huge numbers because now everyone's waiting for the next one, whatever their ideal version of that might sound like.
In that sense, I do have to consider this as another major step in the direction of what popular rap music can sound like. There's something to be said about the way this crossed into the UK & Australian markets in a way that earlier American hits never had the same in-roads for. After years of concessions to pop marketability, it's interesting to see this song revel in the same way more fringe artists have managed to do, by going straight for the jugular and attempting to be the most distinct realisation of one's mental image of this kind of hit. "HUMBLE." sounds big, it's got a very eye-catching music video to go along with it, and it fires on all cylinders of giving the listener something to catch onto while still being lyrically dense in a way that doesn't always allow that. "HUMBLE." has more lyrics in it than the Gang Of Youths song (#177) it beat to the post, despite being barely half its length. That's space for enough words to fit in some curiosities. To my knowledge, it's the only Hottest 100 entry that has ever mentioned Tetris, though this might just be because Tkay Maidza couldn't make the cut with "Shook" (she also mentions it on "24k"). As someone who is always playing Tetris, I approve. I think "Shook" also briefly samples a Kendrick song on its bridge but I've never been able to prove it.
I do find myself wondering about this song as a Hottest 100 winner as well. For one, I think it's good to know that Macklemore isn't the only rapper to do it (also one of those instances where as much as people like to rag on the GRAMMYs, the truth is that the general public largely agreed on this before praxis perceptions took hold). It gives us a redemption story after he missed out two years prior. We don't often get this in Hottest 100 history because the winning songs tend to be the young upstarts, while the Ben Lees, Hilltop Hoods & Keli Holidays of the world have to embrace never getting any closer to glory across the decades. It's also been a vote of populism that had largely gone to white people up to this point, or even songs about how goofy we white people are. Technically in that sense, Kendrick didn't even need to show up because Gang of Youths were there to take the helm if he didn't, and they're also going through their own version of diminishing returns ever since. If there's any truth to the notion that Kendrick won this poll on the basis of making up for past grievances, then those Gang of Youths voters haven't made the same realisation.
That being said, given how relatively low Kendrick polled recently with "Not Like Us", maybe there is some truth to that urgency going missing under the new circumstances. Either that or the song not getting played much on the radio, and finding its biggest cultural peak after the Hottest 100 ("Not Like Us" became Kendrick's first ever lead artist #1 hit in Australia, after the Super Bowl), meant that somehow it wasn't quite as inescapable as it felt. I'm not even sure of my own voting intentions, because I ended up voting for both this song and another from the same album that will eventually appear in this list. I don't think I reached unnecessarily to include "HUMBLE.", but maybe I'd have been less inclined to let him have two of my votes under different standings. That actually accidentally became a very noteworthy thing though because I was the first person to vote in that year's Hottest 100, so there's also a hard to prove but not impossible idea that "HUMBLE." literally was leading the count from the very beginning all the way until the end. It's clearly a big deal kind of song. When Kendrick Lamar came to Australia for the "DAMN." tour, he actually played the song twice in a row, including a version where the crowd would perform a big chunk of it on their own (I was there, I promise I didn't say any words I wasn't supposed to). Maybe it feels a little strange to have this isolated standing as a Hottest 100 winning song just because in a career full of monumental hit songs, this is the only one that's done it, but then I do tend to subscribe to the thought that these kinds of stats are better served to answer debates rather than start them. At the end of the day, the people have spoken, and ordered you to sit down and be humble.

No comments:
Post a Comment